Category archive: Wisconsin

Wisconsin Insurer’s Thorough, Adequate, and Timely Investigation and Proper Settlement Negotiation Tactics Bar Bad Faith and Statutory Pre-Judgment Interest Claims

Summary: Elizabeth Baires was in a car accident with an underinsured driver while insured by State Farm. After State Farm consented to settling with the underinsured motorist for its $100,000 limits, plaintiff and her husband demanded that State Farm settle her claims for the $200,000 UIM stacked limits. State Farm refused her demand, leading to…

Wisconsin Supreme Court: When Subrogating Insurers Aren’t Required to Make Insureds Whole

Summary: Dufour, a motorcyclist insured by Dairyland Insurance Company, was seriously injured while riding his motorcycle, collected full policy limits from the tortfeasor for his bodily injuries and full property damage (PD) and underinsured (UIM) bodily injury (BI) limits from Dairyland, and then sued Dairyland for bad faith when it refused to pay him the…

Overall Good Faith Handling Precluded All Common Law and Most Statutory Bad Faith Contentions

Summary: American Standard’s overall good faith handling of passenger Wahlert’s UIM claim entitled it to summary judgment on the common law bad faith claim and most statutory bad faith contentions. However, its delay in offering to settle for its case valuation amount presented triable issues for a jury. Wahlert v. American Standard Insurance Company of…

The Absence of Bad Faith Diminishes Potential Consequential Damages Award

Summary: Burgraff was injured when a Menard employee was loading Burgraff’s vehicle with materials purchased from Menard. Burgraff’s vehicle and trailer were insured by Millers First Insurance Company (Millers First). Menard was self-insured up to $500,000 and had an excess layer of $500,000 with CNA. During mediation Millers First agreed to settle Burgraff’s claim for…

So Which Rule Applies? Wisconsin Supreme Court Justices Disagree in a Split Decision

Summary: A Wisconsin high school discharged an employee who then sued. The school district’s insurer defended the case through an adverse summary judgment, but refused to indemnify the school district for an adverse judgment even though it had never sent a reservation of rights letter. The majority ruled that the doctrines of waiver or estoppel…

Wow! Wisconsin Supreme Court “Needlessly Alters the Well Established [Bad Faith] Law and Creates… New Pleading Requirements and Uncertain Procedures That are Unnecessary and Confusing.” (Bradley, J.)

Summary: Allstate insured Wanda Brethorst was injured while a passenger in the car her husband was driving. The Allstate policy provided both medpay and uninsured motorist coverages. Allstate paid her medical expenses up to the $5,000.00 medpay limit and offered to pay a small portion of the remaining $4,789.00 in medical expenses to settle the…


St. Louis  |  Clayton  |   Kansas City


Alton  |  Carbondale  |  Edwardsville  |  O'Fallon

The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation.
This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. © 2014 Sandberg Phoenix & von Gontard P.C. All Rights Reserved.